Homes For Sale in Casey Key
Discover Casey Key, Sarasota’s hidden gem, where pristine beaches, lush nature, and luxury living create an unforgettable coastal escape!
Discover Casey Key Real Estate Information
Home Info
Home Types:
Single-Family Homes
Price Range:
$2.0mil - $10.0mil+
Amenities
Beach
Kayak Launch
Fishing
Playground
North Jetty Park
Active Homes For Sale in Casey Key
More Information About Casey Key
Casey Key Homes for Sale: Your Dream Home Awaits in Florida’s Hidden Paradise
Are you searching for the perfect blend of luxury, privacy, and coastal charm? Look no further than Casey Key, Florida—an exclusive barrier island where stunning homes for sale offer prospective buyers a rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise. Nestled between the Gulf of Mexico and Sarasota Bay, Casey Key is a serene, 8-mile-long retreat known for its pristine beaches, upscale real estate, and tranquil lifestyle. Whether you’re dreaming of a gulf-front estate, a bayfront retreat, or a luxurious gulf-to-bay property, Casey Key homes for sale provide an unmatched living experience in Southwest Florida. Let’s explore why Casey Key real estate is the ultimate choice for discerning homebuyers and how you can find your ideal property today.
Why Choose Casey Key, Florida for Your Next Home?
Casey Key is more than just a location—it’s a lifestyle. Located just 15 miles south of downtown Sarasota and a short drive north of Venice, this secluded island offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience. With fewer than 400 residences, Casey Key remains an uncrowded haven, attracting buyers from across the globe who value exclusivity and natural beauty. The island’s slender width—often less than 300 yards—means many Casey Key homes for sale boast breathtaking views of both the Gulf of Mexico and the Intracoastal Waterway, a feature that sets this community apart from other Florida destinations.
Prospective buyers are drawn to Casey Key real estate for its architectural diversity, ranging from charming Old Florida beach cottages to modern Mediterranean-inspired estates. Whether you’re seeking a move-in-ready luxury home or a lot to build your custom dream residence, Casey Key offers something for every taste. The island’s higher ground elevations compared to neighboring barrier islands also make it a standout choice for those prioritizing resilience and safety in their home purchase.
Explore Casey Key Homes for Sale: Luxury Meets Coastal Living
The Casey Key real estate market is synonymous with luxury and exclusivity. Homes for sale in Casey Key, Florida, range from $990,000 to over $10 million, reflecting the premium quality and scarcity of properties on this coveted island. Imagine waking up to the sound of waves crashing on your private beach or sipping your morning coffee with panoramic gulf views from your terrace. Many Casey Key homes for sale feature private docks, infinity pools, gourmet kitchens, and expansive outdoor living spaces—perfect for entertaining or simply enjoying the Florida sunshine.
Gulf-Front Homes for Sale on Casey Key
For buyers seeking direct beach access, gulf-front homes in Casey Key are a top choice. These properties offer unobstructed views of the Gulf of Mexico, private sandy beaches, and the chance to watch stunning sunsets from your own backyard. Prices for gulf-front Casey Key homes for sale typically start at $2 million and can climb significantly higher for larger estates or gulf-to-bay parcels. These homes often include features like floor-to-ceiling windows, spacious lanais, and storm-resistant construction, ensuring both luxury and peace of mind.
Bayfront Properties on Casey Key
If boating is your passion, bayfront homes for sale in Casey Key provide the perfect solution. With deep-water docks and easy access to the Intracoastal Waterway, these properties cater to water enthusiasts looking to explore Sarasota Bay or venture out to the Gulf. Bayfront Casey Key real estate often ranges from $1.5 million to $6 million, offering serene water views and a quieter ambiance compared to gulf-front options. Many of these homes also come with deeded beach access, giving you the best of both worlds.
Gulf-to-Bay Estates: The Pinnacle of Casey Key Real Estate
For the ultimate in luxury, gulf-to-bay homes for sale in Casey Key are the crown jewels of the island. These rare properties span the island’s narrow width, offering private beachfront on one side and a boat dock on the bay side. With lot sizes ranging from half an acre to over five acres, these estates provide unparalleled privacy and versatility. Prices for gulf-to-bay Casey Key homes often start at $5 million and can exceed $10 million, making them a favorite among celebrities, retirees, and affluent buyers seeking a one-of-a-kind residence.
The Casey Key Lifestyle: Privacy, Nature, and Convenience
Living in Casey Key means embracing a laid-back yet luxurious lifestyle. The island’s lack of commercial development ensures a peaceful environment, free from traffic and crowds. Residents enjoy miles of unspoiled beaches, perfect for shelling, swimming, or simply relaxing by the shore. Boating, fishing, and paddleboarding are popular pastimes, thanks to the island’s prime waterfront location. Despite its seclusion, Casey Key is just minutes from Nokomis, where you’ll find grocery stores, dining, and everyday conveniences.
For those who crave culture and entertainment, downtown Sarasota is a short 15-mile drive north. Known as Florida’s “Cultural Coast,” Sarasota offers world-class dining, boutique shopping, and attractions like the Sarasota Opera House and Ringling Museum of Art. To the south, Venice provides additional charm with its historic downtown and vibrant arts scene. Casey Key’s two iconic bridges—the historic Blackburn Point swing bridge and the Albee Road drawbridge—connect you to the mainland, making it easy to enjoy the best of Southwest Florida while retreating to your private oasis.
Why Now is the Time to Buy a Home in Casey Key, Florida
The Casey Key real estate market is highly competitive due to its limited inventory and high demand. With only a handful of homes available at any given time, properties in this exclusive community tend to sell quickly—especially the most desirable gulf-front and gulf-to-bay estates. As of April 2025, the median list price for Casey Key homes for sale hovers around $3.75 million, reflecting the premium value of this unique location. For prospective buyers, acting swiftly is key to securing your dream home before it’s snapped up by another savvy investor or homeowner.
Beyond the investment potential, buying a home in Casey Key offers a chance to join an elite community known for its privacy and prestige. Celebrities, authors, and business moguls have long flocked to Casey Key for its understated elegance and natural splendor. Whether you’re purchasing a primary residence, a vacation home, or a retirement retreat, Casey Key real estate promises a lifestyle that’s as rewarding as it is beautiful.
Finding Your Perfect Casey Key Home: Tips for Prospective Buyers
Ready to start your search for Casey Key homes for sale? Here are some tips to help prospective buyers navigate this exclusive market:
- Define Your Priorities: Are you drawn to gulf-front views, bayfront boating, or a spacious gulf-to-bay estate? Knowing what matters most will narrow your options and streamline your search.
- Work with a Local Expert: Partnering with a real estate agent who specializes in Casey Key properties ensures you’ll have access to the latest listings and insider knowledge of the market.
- Act Quickly: With limited inventory, hesitation can mean missing out. Be prepared to make an offer when you find a home that checks all your boxes.
- Consider Customization: If no current listings meet your needs, explore available lots for sale in Casey Key to build a home tailored to your vision.
- Visit in Person: Photos and virtual tours are helpful, but nothing beats experiencing Casey Key’s charm firsthand. Schedule a visit to walk the beaches and tour properties.
Start Your Casey Key Real Estate Journey Today
Casey Key homes for sale offer prospective buyers a rare chance to own a slice of Florida’s most exclusive coastal paradise. From luxurious gulf-front estates to serene bayfront retreats, the real estate options here cater to those who demand the best in privacy, beauty, and lifestyle. With its prime location near Sarasota and Venice, Casey Key combines the tranquility of island living with easy access to urban amenities—a combination that’s hard to find anywhere else.
Don’t wait to make your dream of owning a Casey Key home a reality. Browse our current listings of Casey Key homes for sale, updated daily from the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), and find the property that speaks to you. Contact our team of Casey Key real estate experts at 941-376-4580 or [email protected] to schedule a private showing or learn more about available homes. Your perfect Florida retreat is waiting—discover Casey Key today!
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why Should I Use a Realtor® When Buying a Home?
A Realtor® brings expertise, market knowledge, and negotiation skills to the home-buying process. We help you find properties that match your specific needs, we guide you through the complex paperwork, and we advocate for your interests during negotiations, potentially saving you time and money.
2. How Much Does it Cost to Use a Realtor® as a Buyer?
In just about all cases, the Buyer’s Real Estate Agent is compensated by the seller’s Real Estate Broker through a commission split agreed upon prior to the property being listed in the MLS. Most if not all real estate companies still charge a nominal transaction fee for processing the transaction paperwork. However, it’s important to confirm this in your Buyer Agent Agreement, as terms can vary.
3. What is a Buyer Agent Agreement, and do I Need One?
A Buyer Agent Agreement is a contract outlining the agent responsibilities, compensation framework, and the duration of your working relationship. (As of August 2024 it is required of all Buyer Agents to have a signed Agreement with a Buyer before showing them a property, or face a $500 fine.) Review it carefully to understand your obligations before signing.
4. What Does a Realtor® do That I Can’t do Myself?
A Realtor® has access to the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) database; tons of market data metrics, and industry connections that are not readily available to the public. They can point you to appropriate lenders, insurers, contractors, inspectors and closing agents; identify and parse through specifically detailed & available properties; streamline the scheduling of showings (timing is important for some properties); provide pricing, property and community insights; confidently negotiate contracts; and coordinate with lenders, inspectors, surveyors, appraisers, title agents, utility companies, contractors and attorneys to ensure a smooth transaction.
5. Can I Buy a Home Without a Realtor®?
Yes, you can buy a home without a Realtor®, but it requires handling all of the complexities of the transaction yourself. A realtor’s expertise will reduce financial and transactional risks, point you in the right direction on all tranactional fronts, most likely save you tens of thousands of dollars through negotiations and lender reccomendations, and streamline the process, all while looking out for your best interests. It is in their best interest to do so – their reputation and return business from clients and referrals is the lifeblood of a Realtor®. Also, this is the largest purchase you may ever make. Do you really want to go at it without your own representation?
6. Can a Realtor® Help me Find Homes That Fit my Budget?
Yes, this is especially important if taxes, insurance and HOA payments are to be considered as a part of your pre-approval process. 3rd party websites do not account for your budget when searching for an available property. A Realtor® can filter listings based on your budget and preferences, ensuring you focus on homes you are capable of purchasing. They can also connect you with lenders to get you pre-approved, giving you a clear picture of your purchasing power.
7. What Paperwork And Legal Requirements Are Involved?
Buying a home involves legal contracts, disclosures, as well as Federal and State regulations. We guide you through preparing the purchase agreement, appropriate disclosures, and all required forms.
8. What Happens During The Negotiation Process?
We work closely with you to create the purchase contract based on price and terms you decide to offer. The offer will be presented to the seller via their agent shortly thereafter. We negotiate on your behalf to secure you the best deal possible. We advise you throughout the entire process.
9. Can a Realtor® Help With New Construction Homes?
Yes, a Realtor® can help you find a new construction community that matches your lifestyle as well as guide you when buying a new construction home, negotiating with builders, reviewing contracts, and ensuring upgrades or warranties are clearly outlined. They can also help you avoid pitfalls specific to new builds.
10. Can a Realtor® Help With For Sale By Owner Homes?
Yes, a Realtor® can help you with For Sale By Owner properties as well. Even though the owner is not using a Real Estate Agent to sell the property, most still offer to pay the Agent’s compensation. The Agent compensation can also be negotiated into the contract if not.
11. What Should I Expect At Closing?
At closing you will sign the final paperwork, including the settlement statement, closing agent disclosures and lender paperwork, if necessary. The closing agent will then file the official Deed (signed by seller) with the county which transfers the title of the property into your name. Don’t forget to bring an ID. We coordinate with the attorney or title company to make sure everyone knows where to be and at what time.
12. What Do I Do After Closing?
You will receive all available keys and copies of closing documents. You can now breathe a sigh of relief, start moving in and plan a house warming party so your friends can buy you stuff you never knew you needed! Congratulations!
Get in Touch with Us Today
Get in Touch with Us Today
ALEX MOREL, REALTOR®
Meet Alex, a Sarasota native with over 40 years of local knowledge and 15 years of experience as a licensed Realtor®. Growing up in a family of home builders and spending a decade in engineering, Alex combines technical expertise with a personalized approach to real estate. Serving Sarasota, Manatee, and Charlotte counties, Alex is dedicated to making your home buying or selling journey seamless and successful.
- Licensed Realtor® since 2010
- Specializes in Residential Real Estate in Sarasota Florida
- Representative For Both Buyers & Sellers
- Member of National, Florida & Sarasota Association of Realtors
- Served on Sarasota Board of Realtors Committee's between 2019-2021
Why Buy a Home on Casey Key With Us?
- Local expertise with in-depth market knowledge.
- Background in residential construction and engineering.
- We specialize in negotiating the best deal for our client.
- We represent you, not the seller.
- Exclusive access to all listings – existing, new and FSBO.
- Seamless process – stress-free buying with expert guidance.
- Personalized service – we match you with your perfect lifestyle.
Alex Morel, Realtor®
Alex will help you navigate the market and find the perfect home that meets your desires.
Start your journey today - fill out the form and let us do the rest!
What Our Clients Are Saying
Real Stories, Real Success: Hear from Happy Homeowners
Trusted Partners and Resources
Collaborating with leading organizations in real estate to bring you reliable insights, tools, and services.
